A kind reader forwarded to me a GREAT "Not an Oreo" ad that you should watch. It, too, is on You Tube.
This is a Utah public school teacher explaining, with stacks and stacks of sandwich creme cookies, just what it takes to run a school.
He highlights that money is spent for many, many things to support every student in the school - counselors, bus transportation, janitors, computer labs, libraries, etc.
AND, he very effectively highlights how efficient schools are because teachers serve hundreds of students.
It's worth a watch, so I hope you will take the time.
It is here, as well as above.
Thank you kind readers for sending me the material. And, thank you fellow bloggers for helping share this good message.
Showing posts with label Oreo cookies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oreo cookies. Show all posts
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Monday, October 29, 2007
The "Anti-Oreo" ad
If you've been following the Utah school voucher issue - and the attendant advertisements - you MUST see this.
It is right on point, although perhaps not 100% factual. But then, the Parents for Choice "Oreo" ad with the famous Eyres isn't even 1% accurate.
Enjoy!
You Tube Video against Referendum One, the "Anti-Oreo" ad is here. YOU TUBE.
It is right on point, although perhaps not 100% factual. But then, the Parents for Choice "Oreo" ad with the famous Eyres isn't even 1% accurate.
Enjoy!
You Tube Video against Referendum One, the "Anti-Oreo" ad is here. YOU TUBE.
Labels:
Bob Aagard,
Oreo cookies,
Referendum 1,
Utah,
Utah Amicus,
vouchers
Thursday, October 11, 2007
What REALLY happens to class size
After listening, time and again, to the convoluted concept that vouchers will reduce class size in Utah's public schools, I wanted to figure out a way to explain how class size really IS determined. Without the Oreo (registered trademark) cookies.
Then I came across this teacher's blog. It is the most succinct explanation of what really happens in Utah's schools, and is based on direct experience. I am pasting the blog in below and including the link. I really hope you will share this widely, for it is the best explanation yet.
The Basics of Class Size - Or Why Vouchers Won't Make a Difference
"I thought I’d explain a bit how class sizes work for those who might believe that commercial with the Oreos the pro-voucher people made.
"Last year we had about 108 sixth grade students at our school. With that number we were able to have four sixth grade teachers, meaning there were about 27 students in each class. This year we are down to 100 sixth grade students. That does not mean that we now have four classes of 25 students. Instead it means we have three classes of 33 students.
"The number of teachers is not a fixed amount. It is determined by how many students there are in the school. So with fewer students in that grade, we were alloted money for fewer teachers.
"And the difference in the number of students wasn’t even that big from last year to this year. And if more sixth graders move into our school, it’s already past the date when we’d hire a new teacher, so the classes will just get bigger.
"So when students leave a public school to attend charter or private schools, it does not result in smaller class sizes. It can often result in larger class sizes. The only thing that would reduce class size would be to allocate more money for teachers so that more could be hired."
Read it here.
Then I came across this teacher's blog. It is the most succinct explanation of what really happens in Utah's schools, and is based on direct experience. I am pasting the blog in below and including the link. I really hope you will share this widely, for it is the best explanation yet.
The Basics of Class Size - Or Why Vouchers Won't Make a Difference
"I thought I’d explain a bit how class sizes work for those who might believe that commercial with the Oreos the pro-voucher people made.
"Last year we had about 108 sixth grade students at our school. With that number we were able to have four sixth grade teachers, meaning there were about 27 students in each class. This year we are down to 100 sixth grade students. That does not mean that we now have four classes of 25 students. Instead it means we have three classes of 33 students.
"The number of teachers is not a fixed amount. It is determined by how many students there are in the school. So with fewer students in that grade, we were alloted money for fewer teachers.
"And the difference in the number of students wasn’t even that big from last year to this year. And if more sixth graders move into our school, it’s already past the date when we’d hire a new teacher, so the classes will just get bigger.
"So when students leave a public school to attend charter or private schools, it does not result in smaller class sizes. It can often result in larger class sizes. The only thing that would reduce class size would be to allocate more money for teachers so that more could be hired."
Read it here.
Labels:
Bob Aagard,
class size,
Oreo cookies,
PCE,
Utah,
Utah Amicus,
vouchers
Tuesday, October 9, 2007
More questions than answers
As I was reading and contemplating Bob Aagard's world here wherein he posits about the absence of media attention to key questions surrounding pro-voucher backers, I followed his link to the accountabilityfirst blog that asked similar questions.
Both just caused me to think of more questions that I wish someone would answer.
For example, why are Richard and Linda Eyre so supportive of vouchers for private school? They don't seem to have a financial stake (yet) in private school operations, though they do sell a pre-school curriculum, noted here.
(As an aside, I noted that the Eyre's "value of the month" is self-reliance. Can someone please tell me what is self-reliant about parents accepting public taxpayer funds to pay for private school? Wouldn't a truly "self-reliant" parent eschew tax dollars and dig deeply into his or her pocket, in a self-reliant way, and pay for their own children?)
Another question for the media: Do PCE, or the Eyres, have trademark permission from Nabisco, et. al. to use Oreo cookies in their demonstrations and TV ads?
If vouchers are so good that stacks of Oreo cookies can be used to demonstrate how wonderful vouchers supposedly are for the public schools, why aren't the Double Stuffed Oreos used? That would make vouchers twice as good! YUM.
Or if truth in advertising is applied to the Eyres' commercial, why are they not forced to use the Oreo 100 calorie snack size since vouchers really are NOT good or yummy for public schools?
Sigh. We may never know.
Both just caused me to think of more questions that I wish someone would answer.
For example, why are Richard and Linda Eyre so supportive of vouchers for private school? They don't seem to have a financial stake (yet) in private school operations, though they do sell a pre-school curriculum, noted here.
(As an aside, I noted that the Eyre's "value of the month" is self-reliance. Can someone please tell me what is self-reliant about parents accepting public taxpayer funds to pay for private school? Wouldn't a truly "self-reliant" parent eschew tax dollars and dig deeply into his or her pocket, in a self-reliant way, and pay for their own children?)
Another question for the media: Do PCE, or the Eyres, have trademark permission from Nabisco, et. al. to use Oreo cookies in their demonstrations and TV ads?
If vouchers are so good that stacks of Oreo cookies can be used to demonstrate how wonderful vouchers supposedly are for the public schools, why aren't the Double Stuffed Oreos used? That would make vouchers twice as good! YUM.
Or if truth in advertising is applied to the Eyres' commercial, why are they not forced to use the Oreo 100 calorie snack size since vouchers really are NOT good or yummy for public schools?
Sigh. We may never know.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)